The Turkish Journal of Pediatrics
| |
|
[Summary]
[PDF]
[Mail to Editor ]
[Back]
|
|
Severe Quadriparesis Caused by Wasp Sting
|
|
Peter Bánovčin, Zuzana Havlíčeková, Miloš Jeseňák, Slavomír Nosáľ, Peter Ďurdík,
Miriam Čiljaková, Ján Mikler
|
|
Department of Pediatrics, Comenius University in Bratislava, Jessenius School of Medicine, Martin, Slovakia
|
| Summary | | Besides the typical symptoms of allergic reaction after wasp sting, unusual
and unexpected reactions may also develop. In this report, a case of severe
peripheral quadriparesis and sphincteric disorder (urinary incontinence) in
a 10–year-old boy occurring within 24 hours after wasp sting is presented.
Corticosteroids had very good therapeutic effect, and improvement in clinical
status was observed within 72 hours. The exact pathogenic mechanism of
peripheral nervous system damage is not very well known. Several studies
have suggested that besides the neurotoxic effect of wasp venom, delayed
immunological response to wasp antigens followed by an allergy-triggered
autoimmune reaction is possible. Wasp venom may activate an allergic
reaction or effects by toxic impacts; however, typical clinical symptoms of
allergic reaction are not necessarily present. |
|
Keywords:
children, quadriparesis, sphincteric disorder, wasp.c
|
| Introduction | | Wasps together with hornets and bees are
members of the order Hymenoptera. Their
sting can induce a variety of responses - from
slight local reactions to severe life-threatening
events. Hymenoptera venom can activate allergic
reaction or effects by toxic impacts; however,
typical symptoms of allergic reaction are not
necessarily present. It is well known that wasp
and bee venoms belong to the strongest animal
allergens. Wasp venoms show variability in their
composition among species. In general, wasp
venom consists of three bases – active amines
(serotonin, histamine, tyramine, epinephrine
and dopamine) and amino acids (tryptophan,
histidine), enzymes and polypeptides (vespakinin,
mastoparan and chemotactic peptides). The major
allergens in wasp venoms are phospholipase A2,
hyaluronidase and antigen 5. Phospholipase A2
acts as a cytotoxin and an indirect cytolysin
and also has neurotoxic activity by blocking
neurotransmission on neural synapse.
We report a case of severe peripheral quadriparesis
in a 10-year-old boy occurring after wasp sting.nical+s |
| Case Presentation | | A 10-year-old boy with weakness in his upper
extremities and difficulties with standing and
walking was presented for evaluation.
He was born at term as a fifth child after
physiological pregnancy. His morbidity was
appropriate and he did not suffer from any
chronic disease or take any drugs. There was
no previous clinical history of allergic reaction.
He had been bitten by a tick nine months
before without any local or subsequent systemic
reaction. In the previous month, before the
development of clinical signs, the patient had
no health problems or accidents and he had
not been vaccinated.
His older sister was treated for epilepsy; his
father had diabetes and suffered three strokes
at the age of 53 years.
The patient had been stung by a wasp, and
local reaction on his right hand developed
within 24 hours. He felt well and had no other
complaints. The local reaction had regressed
slightly after local application of antihistamine
(dimetindeni maleas 0.1%). After 28 hours,
weakness in his upper extremities developed
and he soon had difficulties with standing and
walking. He complained of mild persistent
headache. After 32 hours, he was admitted
to a regional Department of Pediatrics. He
was afebrile and conscious, and vital signs
were normal. Physical examination revealed
allergic swelling on his right hand. Neurologicalsting
evaluation showed peripheral paraparesis of
the lower extremities, accented on the right
side, and minimal weakness of the upper
extremities. Upper and lower meningeal signs
were negative, and there were no sensitive
deficit, paresthesias or leg pain. In laboratory
tests on admission, inflammatory markers and
complete blood cells count were within normal
range, whereas creatinine phosphokinase
(11.91 ƒÊkat/L; normal value: 0-4.12 ƒÊkat/L)
and aspartate aminotransferase (0.85 ƒÊkat/L;
normal value: 0.1-0.58 ƒÊkat/L) were elevated
in blood chemistry. Intravenous anti-allergic
(antihistamine, systemic corticosteroids) and
polyvitamin therapy were started immediately.
However, the disease had progressed despite
therapy. After 40 hours, quadriparesis and
sphincteric disorder (urinary incontinence)
had developed.
The patient was referred to our department
on the second day after the wasp sting. The
general physical examination was normal at
admission. Neurologically, he was alert and
awake, without objective sensory abnormalities
and paresthesias, and cranial nerves innervation
was intact. He had diffuse muscle weakness,
evident on lower extremities and less marked
on upper extremities. Deep tendon reflexes
were not present on lower extremities, and
were markedly decreased on upper extremities.
Sphincteric disorder - urinary incontinence
developed. Guillain-Barre syndrome, central
nervous system inflammatory disease,
toxo-allergic polyradiculoneuropathy, and
neuroborreliosis were taken into consideration
in the context of differential diagnosis. In
laboratory tests, persisted inflammatory markers
and complete blood cells count were within the
normal range, while elevated levels of creatinine
phosphokinase and aspartate aminotransferase
were determined. Urinalysis and evaluation
of renal function revealed no abnormality.
Kidney and urinary tract ultrasound revealed
no pathology. The immunological examination
showed combined immunodeficiency of both
specific and non-specific cellular immunity
(decreased absolute T-cell count and phagocytic
activity), and immunoglobulins G, A and
M levels were within physiological ranges.
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis for
neurotropic viruses (influenza A, B; herpes
simplex virus 1, 2; varicella-zoster virus;
Epstein-Barr virus; cytomegalovirus) and
serology for Borrelia (IgG, IgM) were negative.
Total IgE levels were not elevated and venomspecific
IgE levels to wasp and bee were low
(class I positivity, which usually does not cause
reactions), and also again two months after
wasp sting. A lumbar puncture was done within
48 hours after wasp sting. The cerebrospinal
fluid was clear and liquor pressure was normal.
Basal chemistry tests - cell counts (erythrocytes 2;
normal value (N): 0-5/3; polymorphonuclear cells
0, N: 0-3/3; lymphocytes 2, N: 0-5/3), glucose
(2.6 mmol/L, N: 1.8-4.6 mmol/L), chloride
(121 mmol/L, N: 113-131 mmol/L) and total
protein (0.27 g/L, N: 0.10-0.45 g/L) were within
the normal range, without albumin-cytologic
dissociation. Electrophoresis of cerebrospinal fluid
proteins detected elevated albumin (0.608 U;
N: 0.371-0.459 U) and alpha 2 globulin (0.077 U;
N: 0.035-0.063 U) levels. The cerebrospinal fluid
culture was sterile. Imaging studies (magnetic
resonance imaging [MRI] scan of the brain
and spinal column, MRI-angiography of brain
blood vessels) did not reveal any pathology.
Electromyogram performed on the fifth day
after the wasp sting showed normal findings
without any signs of peripheral nervous system
neuropathy, with the exception of the F wave
absence (the absence of this graphoelement
is considered to be a non-specific sign of
polyneuropathy). We had proceeded with
corticotherapy (dexamethasone 1 mg/kg/day
intravenously in 4 divided doses for the first
4 days and then successive detraction of the
dose for the next 10 days), neuroprotective
therapy and rehabilitation. After 72 hours, we
observed slow improvement in his clinical state
.motility of first the upper and then of the lower
extremities improved. Mild headache completely
disappeared within two weeks. He was discharged
after three weeks with a diagnosis of toxo-allergic
polyradiculoneuropathy caused by wasp sting.
Neurological findings included mild peripheral
paraparesis of lower extremities accented on the
right side and urinary incontinence; laboratory
tests were normal. |
| Discussion | | Reactions to insect stings are a frequent
medical problem. The purpose of the diagnostic
procedure is to classify a sting reaction by
history, identify the underlying pathogenic
mechanism, and identify the insect. Prevalence
of Hymenoptera sting reactions varies. Reactions
to Hymenoptera stings are classified into
normal local reactions, large local reactions,
systemic toxic reactions, systemic anaphylactic
reactions, and unusual reactions. Most of the
studies reported that large local reactions
occur in 10.6-26.4%[1], [2] and systemic reactions
in 0.66-3.3%[1]-[3] of the general population.
Venom hypersensitivity may be mediated by
immunologic mechanisms (IgE-mediated or
non-IgE-mediated venom allergy) but also
by non-immunologic mechanisms, which are
responsible for a minority of insect sting
reactions. They are mediated by short-term
sensitizing IgG antibodies or complement
activation by IgG-venom immune complexes4.
Negative venom-specific IgE could also be due
to insufficient sensitivity of tests used or to a
long interval from the sting-induced reaction
to the testing with spontaneous decline in
venom-specific IgE.
Local and acute systemic allergic reactions caused
by wasp stings are well known. Unusual and
unexpected reactions, which can develop from
within a few hours to weeks, have been rarely
reported in relation to wasp sting. Most often,
renal diseases have been described following
single or multiple wasp stings. Acute renal
failure after wasp sting, which is the most
frequent event, is caused by acute tubular
necrosis in consequence of hemolysis or
rhabdomyolysis[5], direct nephrotoxic effect[5] or
acute interstitial nephritis due to hypersensitivity
reaction to the wasp venom[6],[7]. Wasp venom
can seldom induce acute myocardial infarction.
Cardiovascular symptoms are provoked by
vasoactive, inflammatory and thrombogenic
components of wasp venom; allergic reaction is
not necessarily present[8],[9]. Other reactions, such as
rhabdomyolysis[5] or lupus erythematosus were also
rarely mentioned in the literature. Neurological
complications after wasp sting are rarely reviewed
in the literature. They generally develop from
within a few hours to weeks after the sting.
Reactions such as Guillain-Barré, myasthenia
gravis, multiple sclerosis, cerebral infarction,
encephalomyelitis, neuropathies (polyneuropathy
or optic neuropathy), and demyelinating
diseases have been observed[10]-[15]. A few cases
of polyneuropathy after wasp sting are known.
Agarwal et al.[16] presented a case of progressive
generalized weakness and quadriparesis of three
hours duration in a 30-year-old man after wasp
sting. Anti-allergic therapy was given nine
hours after the accident. However, symptoms
appeared after five hours and were probably
caused by acute inflammatory demyelinating
polyneuropathy following hypersensitivity to the
wasp sting. Likattanasombut et al.[13] described
development of encephalomyeloradiculopathy
with impaired consciousness and quadriplegia in
an 18-year-old man 16 days after wasp sting. His
clinical status improved after methylprednisolone
treatment and plasma exchange. Ridolo et al.[15]
reported a case of a 51-year-old man with acute
polyradiculoneuropathy occurring 40 hours after a
second wasp sting. After the first wasp sting, the
man underwent venom immunotherapy. He had
muscle weakness, paresthesias, and difficulties in
standing up and walking. Skin tests and specific
IgE measurement confirmed IgE-mediated allergy
to wasp.
The exact pathogenic mechanism of peripheral
nervous system damage after wasp sting is not
very clear. It was hypothesized that besides
the neurotoxic effect of wasp venom, delayed
immunological response to wasp antigens
followed by an allergy-triggered autoimmune
reaction could be responsible for the clinical
reactions[13],[15]. Corticosteroids showed very good
therapeutic effect in previous cases.
In this case report, we want to stress that besides
the typical symptoms of allergic reaction after
wasp sting, unusual and unexpected reactions
may also develop. To our knowledge, this is the
first report of sphincteric disorder following wasp
sting as a part of a complex clinical presentation
in the Central European region. A possible
explanation for the incontinence could be direct
toxicity of wasp venom, or this clinical sign
could be the consequence of a slowly developing
immune reaction, although sufficient explanatory
data in the literature does not exist. |
| Reference | 1. Fernandez J, Blanca M, Soriano V, Sanchez J, Juarez
C. Epidemiological study of the prevalence of allergic
reactions to Hymenoptera in a rural population in
the Mediterranean area. Clin Exp Allergy 1999; 29:
1069-1074.
2. Incorvaia C, Senna G, Mauro M, et al. Prevalence of
allergic reactions to Hymenoptera stings in northern
Italy. Allerg Immunol 2004; 36: 372-374.
3. Charpin D, Birnbaum J, Lanteaume A, Vervloet D.
Prevalence of allergy to hymenoptera stings in different
samples of the general population. J Allergy Clin
Immunol 1992; 90: 331-334
4. Bil BM, Rueff F, Mosbech M, Bonifazi F, Oude-Elberink
JN & the EAACI Interest Group on Insect Venom
Hypersensitivity. Diagnosis of Hymenoptera venom
allergy. Allergy 2005; 60: 1339-1349.
5. Vikrant S, Pandey D, Machhan P, Gupta D, Kaushal
SS, Grover N. Wasp envenomation-induced acute renal
failure. A report of three cases. Nephrology 2005; 10:
548-552.
6. Beccari M, Castiglione A, Cavaliere G, et al. Direct
tubular toxicity of hymenoptera venom. Nephron 1992;
61: 477.
7. Zhang R, Meleg-Smith S, Batuman V. Acute tubulointerstitial
nephritis after wasp sting. Am J Kidney
Dis 2001; 38: 33.
8. Calveri G, Bertelli Y, Caico SI, et al. Acute myocardial
infarction after wasp sting. Ital Heart J Suppl 2002;
3: 555-557.
9. Bongo AS, Fornaro G, Sansa M, Maccio S, Rognoni
A. Acute myocardial infarction after wasp sting
without anaphylactic reaction. Ital Heart J Suppl 2005;
6: 178-182.
10. Meszaros I. Transient cerebral ischemic attack caused
by Hymenoptera stings: the brain as an anaphylactic
shock organ. Eur Neurol 1986; 25: 248-252.
11. Dionne AJ, Griffith A, Levin M, Stommel EW.
Exacerbation of multiple sclerosis following wasp
sting. Mayo Clin Proc 2000; 75: 317-318.
12. Maltzman JS, Lee AG, Miller NR. Optic neuropathy
occurring after bee and wasp sting. Ophthalmology
2000; 107: 193-195.
13. Likittanasombut P, Witoonpanich R, Viranuvatti K.
Encephalomyeloradiculopathy associated with wasp sting.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003; 74: 134-135.
14. Hira HS, Mittal A, Kumar SA, Singh A, Ahalawat
RS. Myasthenia gravis and acute respiratory muscle
paralysis following wasp sting. Indian J Chest Dis
Allied Sci 2005; 47: 197-198.
15. Ridolo E, Albertini R, Borghi L, Meschi T, Montanari E,
Dall’Aglio PP. Acute polyradiculoneuropathy occurring
after hymenoptera stings: a clinical case study. Int J
Imunopathol Pharmacol 2005; 18: 385-390.
16. Agarwal V, D’Cruz S, Sachdev A, Singh R, Kapoor
V. Quadriparesis following wasp sting: an unusual
reaction. Indian J Med Sci 2005; 59: 117-119s |
|
[Summary ]
[PDF]
[Mail to Editor ]
[Back]
|
|
|